Coin Voting ZIP #853

hhanh00 · 2024-05-28T05:22:51Z

I added the rendered html file because I couldn't find a suitable markdown renderer.
mdbook renders multiple files
github flavored markdown doesn't support callouts

str4d

Initial review of the draft at a high level, with @arya2, @conradoplg, and @daira. We have not yet reviewed the proposed process or any specification details.

str4d · 2024-06-04T17:19:44Z

protocol/blossom.pdf

Action item: @daira to liaise with @hhanh00 to rebase this PR on current main (to remove the changes to other files, now that we have fixed the automatic renderer), and adjust the Markdown to render correctly within the ZIPs renderer.

str4d · 2024-06-04T17:23:37Z

zip-0340.md

@hhanh00 per ZIP 0:

This draft must be [..] named with an alias such as draft-zatoshizakamoto-42millionzec until the ZIP Editors have assigned it a ZIP number (Owners MUST NOT self-assign ZIP numbers).

Rename this file to something like draft-hhanh00-coin-voting.md, and remove all references to the self-assigned ZIP number in outside locations.

str4d · 2024-06-04T17:33:03Z

zip-0340.md

+---
+title: Coin Voting
+breaks: false
+tags: coin_voting
+---


Per ZIP 0, there are several required headers that you need to include, as well as some optional headers that may be useful. A suggested header:

Suggested change

---

title: Coin Voting

breaks: false

tags: coin_voting

---

ZIP: TBD

Title: Coin Voting

Owners: Your Name <your@email>

Status: Draft

Category: Process / Ecosystem

Created: 2024-05-28 (or whenever the draft ZIP was first created outside the repo)

License: Pick one from https://zips.z.cash/zip-0000#zip-licensing

Discussions-To: Link to wherever this is being discussed (zcash/zips issue, forum thread, etc.)

str4d · 2024-06-04T17:34:54Z

zip-0340.md

+tags: coin_voting
+---
+
+# Coin Voting


Per ZIP 0 and the ZIP guide, we don't have a top-level title that duplicates the header. This section appears to instead be the abstract:

Suggested change

# Coin Voting

# Abstract

str4d · 2024-06-04T17:37:26Z

zip-0340.md

+This ZIP describes a mechanism for the organization of
+coin-weighted election. 
+
+## Use Case


A use cases section is useful (see e.g. #426 for an example of this):

Suggested change

## Use Case

# Use Case

However, a ZIP should also have a # Motivation section (see ZIP 0), so to the extent that content in this section is describing a general motivation for the ZIP rather than a specific use case, that content should be moved into a Motivation section before the Use Cases section.

If this section is intended to be the motivation, then rename it:

Suggested change

## Use Case

# Motivation

str4d · 2024-06-04T17:55:23Z

zip-0340.md

+A possible solution is suggested in 
+[Air drops, Proof-of-Balance, and Stake-weighted Polling](https://hackmd.io/ujald5ElTMumppM7juk2WA?both)


This should be replaced by a reference to draft-str4d-orchard-balance-proof.md once #848 has merged.

str4d · 2024-06-04T17:57:24Z

zip-0340.md

+:::info
+The EB publishes all ballots and their opening keys for verification
+by auditors.
+:::


ZIP is missing a References section:

Suggested change

:::

:::

# References

TBD

str4d · 2024-06-04T18:01:25Z

zip-0340.md

+- The EB MAY set special rules for the election. For example,
+there MAY be a fee for casting a vote or a minimum ZEC requirement
+
+## Privacy


This section currently describes how privacy issues could be solved. The ZIP will eventually instead need to address how privacy issues are solved.

Most of this content should be moved to a Security and Privacy Considerations section, that will evolve as the ZIP draft is updated to address privacy issues. The only paragraph that should remain here is the one that includes conformance requirements.

If there are open questions about how to solve concerns that are given in the Security and Privacy Considerations section, add an Open Questions section outlining them (that can become a topic for discussion).

str4d · 2024-06-04T18:03:32Z

zip-0340.md

+To mitigate this issue, the user SHOULD be offered to move
+their coins after a vote. However, if multiple elections
+are carried out concurrently with similar snapshot
+heights, it will be impossible for a Voter to participate
+in both without linking their votes.


This is the one paragraph that should stay in the Specification section.

Also, conformance requirements should be specific about what parties they place requirements upon:

Suggested change

To mitigate this issue, the user SHOULD be offered to move

their coins after a vote. However, if multiple elections

are carried out concurrently with similar snapshot

heights, it will be impossible for a Voter to participate

in both without linking their votes.

Wallets SHOULD offer to move their user's coins after a vote. However, if

multiple elections are carried out concurrently with similar snapshot heights,

it will be impossible for a Voter to participate in both without linking their

votes.

str4d · 2024-06-04T18:05:26Z

zip-0340.md

+:::warning
+The Voter SHOULD not reuse the signing key!
+:::
+


This is where the Security and Privacy considerations section should go:

Suggested change

# Security and privacy considerations

TBD

hhanh00 and others added 30 commits May 28, 2024 15:20

Coin Voting ZIP

541fa09

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

ea9f2a1

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

bbe2a9f

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

a35e13f

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

9c7bbd7

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

7eed6f2

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

53fe9c9

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

7b52bec

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

d84527e

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

647708c

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

ebebc89

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

856471b

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

ca50177

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

a348933

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

ad7620d

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

b35fb97

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

299c1da

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

b391f0d

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

c0b3a18

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

524441c

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

808ee8d

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

8d5d923

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

af50890

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

bc7ebde

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

22091a3

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

8dbc9eb

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

e99bea4

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

683977e

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

9121dd8

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

6c19fee

github-actions bot added 29 commits May 28, 2024 17:26

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

53e21ff

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

ecad587

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

0da43a3

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

7472a74

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

2215aef

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

1258327

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

a8480a4

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

78e0fad

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

c60d45e

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

8263e6e

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

8f3f264

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

3f222be

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

623cddf

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

406d257

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

244b7b3

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

75df17d

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

27a3df9

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

28b769c

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

e71f8ce

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

7e092ad

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

4ac7c6a

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

c137348

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

29faec5

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

79eebea

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

c2fd27d

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

5700744

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

4304165

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

7af0853

Commit from GitHub Actions (Build tex and rst)

d006de1

str4d requested changes Jun 4, 2024

View reviewed changes

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Coin Voting ZIP #853

Coin Voting ZIP #853

hhanh00 commented May 28, 2024

str4d left a comment

str4d Jun 4, 2024

str4d Jun 4, 2024

str4d Jun 4, 2024

str4d Jun 4, 2024

str4d Jun 4, 2024

str4d Jun 4, 2024

str4d Jun 4, 2024

str4d Jun 4, 2024

str4d Jun 4, 2024

str4d Jun 4, 2024

----
-title: Coin Voting
-breaks: false
-tags: coin_voting
----
+    ZIP: TBD
+    Title: Coin Voting
+    Owners: Your Name <your@email>
+    Status: Draft
+    Category: Process / Ecosystem
+    Created: 2024-05-28 (or whenever the draft ZIP was first created outside the repo)
+    License: Pick one from https://zips.z.cash/zip-0000#zip-licensing
+    Discussions-To: Link to wherever this is being discussed (zcash/zips issue, forum thread, etc.)

		A possible solution is suggested in
		[Air drops, Proof-of-Balance, and Stake-weighted Polling](https://hackmd.io/ujald5ElTMumppM7juk2WA?both)

-:::
+:::
+# References
+TBD

Coin Voting ZIP #853

Are you sure you want to change the base?

Coin Voting ZIP #853

Conversation

hhanh00 commented May 28, 2024

str4d left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment