Merge pull request #192 from davidz25/main

Add 2024 annual review for Identity Credential.

docs/projects/reviews/2024/2024-identity-credential-annual.md

@@ -0,0 +1,75 @@
+# 2024 identity-credential (Identity Credential)
+
+## Project Health
+
+The goal of the project is to create libraries to enable easy construction
+of real-world digital identity applications, including wallets, readers, and
+issuance/provisioning systems.
+
+The initial focus for this work was mdoc/mDL according to ISO/IEC 18013-5:2021
+and related standards (mainly ISO 23220 series and ISO 18013-7) but the
+current scope also include other credential formats (including SD-JWT VC)
+and presentation and provisioning protocols (ISO, OpenID, and
+[W3C Digital Credentials](https://wicg.github.io/digital-credentials/))
+
+The project is healthy and contributions have increased steadily over the
+past 12 months. Several individuals are contributing code on a regular
+basis.
+
+## Maintainer Diversity
+
+The project has 9 maintainers on file and they all work for Google. This is
+an increase from last year where we had around 5 maintainers.
+
+## Project Adoption
+
+Several entities use these libraries in one shape or another, the most
+prominent examples being [Google Wallet](https://wallet.google/) and the
+[EUDI Wallet Reference Implementation](https://github.com/eu-digital-identity-wallet/.github/blob/main/profile/reference-implementation.md).
+The code is also used in several other places, including both wallet and
+reader applications.
+
+Google is using this code as a base for its participation in the
+[SPRIN-D EUDI Wallet Funke competition](https://www.sprind.org/en/impulses/challenges/eudi-wallet-prototypes).
+
+## Goals
+
+### Performance Against Prior Goals
+
+By the beginning of 2024, the team set out the following goals of which all
+are almost 100% completed:
+
+- Conversion to Kotlin: All code was ported from Java.
+- SD-JWT support: Completed (and show-cases in SPRIN-D Funke)
+- Wallet Server: Designed and implemented a wallet backend.
+- Cloud Secure Area: Designed and implemented a Cloud Secure Area.
+- Wallet rewrite: We rewrote the sample app included in our repo to showcase how to best use the libraries
+- W3C Digital Credentials API: The project served as a test-bench for the Android/Chrome engineers working on this as well as the rest of the ecosystem.
+- iOS support: Partially completed, expected to be 100% complete early next year.
+- Releasing: We made two releases, one in August and one in November.
+
+### Next Year's Goals
+
+The tentative goals for 2025 include
+
+- New name
+- Convert Wallet App to Compose Multiplatform, for iOS support.
+- Add module/extension system
+- Address technical debt, stabilize code
+- Work on developer documentation
+- Regular releases (every two months or so)
+- Publish Wallet App to Google Play and Apple App Store
+- Stand up Wallet Server (for Wallet App instances from marketplaces to connect to)
+- Stand up test issuers / relying parties (for Wallet App instances to use)
+- Implement ZKP protocols: We are working with cryptographers and SDOs on devising new presentation protocols based on Zero-Knowledge Proofs.
+
+## Help Required
+
+The project is in good shape and does not require any help at the moment.
+
+## Project Lifecycle Stage Recommendation
+
+Most of the work done in 2024 was about creating a solid foundation for
+future work, including converting to Kotlin Multiplatform. We are almost
+done with  this but not quite and we expect a couple of additional iterations
+of changes. As such we'd like to stay in the Labs stage for the next year.

docs/projects/reviews/2024/index.md

@@ -3,13 +3,13 @@
 Projects must provide an [annual review](../../../governance/project-annual-review-process.md) to the TAC to ensure that the project is still active and in the correct [lifecycle stage](../../../governance/project-lifecycle.md#stages). The following calendar provides the timing for when these reviews are required to be presented to the TAC:
 
 | Project                       | Stage  | Date Accepted | 2024 Review  |
-| ----------------------------- | ------ | ------------- | ------------ |
+|-------------------------------| ------ | ------------- | ------------ |
 | [SD-JWT Python]               | Labs   | May 27, 2023  | Jun 12, 2024 |
 | [SD-JWT Kotlin]               | Labs   | May 27, 2023  | Jun 12, 2024 |
 | [Farmworker Wallet OS]        | Labs   | Aug  9, 2023  | Aug 21, 2024 |
 | [VC-API]                      | Labs   | Sep 28, 2023  | Oct  2, 2024 |
 | Wallet Framework .NET         | Labs   | Oct  4, 2023  | Oct 16, 2024 |
-| Android Identity Library      | Labs   | Oct 18, 2023  | Oct 30, 2024 |
+| [Identity Credential]         | Labs   | Oct 18, 2023  | Oct 30, 2024 |
 | SD-JWT JavaScript             | Labs   | Nov  1, 2023  | Nov 13, 2024 |
 | SD-JWT Rust                   | Labs   | Nov 15, 2023  | Nov 27, 2024 |
 | Credo                         | Growth | Nov 29, 2023  | Dec 11, 2024 |
@@ -18,4 +18,5 @@ Projects must provide an [annual review](../../../governance/project-annual-revi
 [SD-JWT Python]: ./2024-sd-jwt-python-annual.md
 [SD-JWT Kotlin]: ./2024-sd-jwt-kotlin-annual.md
 [Farmworker Wallet OS]: ./2024-farmworker-wallet-os-annual.md
-[VC-API]: ./2024-vc-api-implementation-annual.md
+[VC-API]: ./2024-vc-api-implementation-annual.md
+[Identity Credential]: ./2024-identity-credential-annual.md