Inconsistent inference results affecting redefined-variable-type messages

[jacobtylerwalls]

next on the list of offending messages(*) causing primer noise:

(*) likely nothing wrong with the message, just something wrong with inconsistent inference results

compare:

pylint music21 --enable=redefined-variable-type --disable=all --enable-all-extensions

to:

pylint music21 --enable=redefined-variable-type,no-member --disable=all --enable-all-extensions

Produces this diff:

diff --git a/a.out b/a.out
index b6688d824..623a87c89 100644
--- a/a.out
+++ b/a.out
@@ -154,8 +154,6 @@ music21/mei/test_base.py:5039: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), Test.testCoreInt
 music21/mei/base.py:1372: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), metaSetDate] Redefinition of meta.dateCreated type from music21.metadata.primitives.Date to music21.metadata.primitives.DateBetween
 music21/mei/base.py:2192: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), noteFromElement] Redefinition of theNote type from music21.pitch.Pitch to music21.note.Note
 music21/mei/base.py:2240: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), noteFromElement] Redefinition of theNote.duration type from music21.duration.Duration to music21.duration.GraceDuration
-music21/mei/base.py:2310: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), restFromElement] Redefinition of theRest type from music21.note.Rest to list
-music21/mei/base.py:2358: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), spaceFromElement] Redefinition of theSpace type from music21.note.Rest to list
 music21/mei/base.py:2450: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), chordFromElement] Redefinition of theChord type from list to music21.chord.Chord
 music21/mei/base.py:2483: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), chordFromElement] Redefinition of theChord.duration type from music21.duration.Duration to music21.duration.GraceDuration
 ************* Module music21.lily.translate
@@ -167,6 +165,7 @@ music21/search/segment.py:154: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), _indexSingleMult
 ************* Module music21.common.numberTools
 music21/common/numberTools.py:411: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), mixedNumeral] Redefinition of quotient type from float to int
 ************* Module music21.abcFormat.translate
+music21/abcFormat/translate.py:381: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), parseABCNote] Redefinition of n type from music21.note.Note to music21.note.GeneralNote
 music21/abcFormat/translate.py:554: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), abcToStreamOpus] Redefinition of opus type from music21.stream.base.Opus to music21.stream.base.Score
 ************* Module music21.abcFormat
 music21/abcFormat/__init__.py:967: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), ABCBar.getBarObject] Redefinition of m21bar type from music21.bar.Repeat to music21.bar.Barline
@@ -188,7 +187,7 @@ music21/humdrum/spineParser.py:667: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), HumdrumData
 music21/humdrum/spineParser.py:1276: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), HumdrumSpine.parse] Redefinition of thisObject type from music21.humdrum.spineParser.MiscTandem to music21.stream.base.Measure
 music21/humdrum/spineParser.py:1460: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), DynamSpine.parse] Redefinition of thisObject type from music21.humdrum.spineParser.MiscTandem to music21.humdrum.spineParser.SpineComment
 music21/humdrum/spineParser.py:1513: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), HarmSpine.parse] Redefinition of thisObject type from music21.humdrum.spineParser.MiscTandem to music21.stream.base.Measure
-music21/humdrum/spineParser.py:2386: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), hdStringToNote] Redefinition of thisObject type from music21.note.Note to music21.note.GeneralNote
+music21/humdrum/spineParser.py:2383: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), hdStringToNote] Redefinition of thisObject type from music21.note.Note to music21.note.Rest
 ************* Module music21.meter.tools
 music21/meter/tools.py:410: [R0204(redefined-variable-type), divisionOptionsAdditiveMultiples] Redefinition of seq type from list to tuple
 ************* Module music21.meter.core

[jacobtylerwalls]

Fixed in #9887. Thanks @akamat10!!

[akamat10]

No problem! Correction: Fixed in pylint-dev/astroid#2572

[jacobtylerwalls]

Interesting. I reverted #9887 and it reproduced the issue for me.

[akamat10]

Interesting! It also makes sense since it was causing non-deterministic behavior. pylint-dev/astroid#2572 addressed issue with errors caused by cache not clearing from previous repos in the primer run.

[jacobtylerwalls]

Right, I was alerted to this by the primer, but the reproducer above doesn't involve the primer or cache clearing.

[akamat10]

Ah! I was confused. Glad this can be also closed.