Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Crashes on M1 Big Sur 11.5.2 / Ableton and Bitwig #1823

Closed
wrkdat opened this issue Aug 25, 2024 · 23 comments
Closed

Crashes on M1 Big Sur 11.5.2 / Ableton and Bitwig #1823

wrkdat opened this issue Aug 25, 2024 · 23 comments

Comments

@wrkdat
Copy link

wrkdat commented Aug 25, 2024

hence the title, couldn't get AU / VST / VST3 and CLAP to work, always the " A serious Problem, will shut down immediately" warning occurs.

I installed and used it on my Mac around 4 months ago with no problems!

Please help!
thanks in advance! 🖤

@timothyschoen
Copy link
Collaborator

Hi!

When does this crash happen? On startup, or when using a specific patch?

@wrkdat
Copy link
Author

wrkdat commented Aug 25, 2024

hi!
on start up with every format. vst vst 3 au clap etc. couldn't even load a patch. previous version 4 month ago worked fine, except some little bugs like cpu spikes, that werent releated to a patch.

@wrkdat
Copy link
Author

wrkdat commented Aug 26, 2024

if you need any more info please let me know. again i can't install universal AND legacy, both do not work (anymore)

tested on two Version of Bitwig and Ableton Live 10,11,12

thanks in advance!

@lockee951
Copy link

Hi,

brandnew to Plugsdata and Github. Just for the Info

I got the same crash on trying to load Plugdata in Bitwig 5.2.1 on Mac M1 with Vst3 and Clap

regards Laurent

@wrkdat
Copy link
Author

wrkdat commented Aug 27, 2024

HELP HELP HELP

@lockee951
Copy link

HELP HELP HELP

👀

@lockee951
Copy link

I have tried it with the
"Merge pull request #1825 from alcomposer/button-fixes #6025" built. The same crash with both Clap and Vst3.

@timothyschoen
Copy link
Collaborator

Hi! I'll take a look at the as soon as I can! It's strange because I'm running on a 2020 M1 MBP myself, and I don't have this issue :(

@lockee951
Copy link

Hi, yes this sounds a bit strange. I'am running a MBP M1 (2022) as well. I will tty to install an older version and test if this work and report back.

Regards and thank you for looking at it 😌

@timothyschoen
Copy link
Collaborator

timothyschoen commented Aug 28, 2024

For anyone who has these crashes, can you find a crash report?

On macOS, you might be able to find them in the "Console" application. Select "Crash Reports" in the sidepanel, and then look for processes that belong to Logic, Bitwig or Ableton.

For Logic, it will probably be called "AUHostingServiceXPC_Arrow". For Ableton, just "ableton". Not sure about Bitwig.

But if I had some crash reports, that would help a lot!

@lockee951
Copy link

I am quite new to Mac... i will try later to find this "console" app and the belobging file from Bitwig 🤞

@offchristianamr
Copy link

offchristianamr commented Sep 8, 2024

Having the same issue using 0.9.1 with Monterey 12.7.2 on my M1 Pro macbook — instant crash as soon as I attempt to open Plugdata (AU or VST3) in Ableton Live 12 ;(
The plugin begins to load, then the crash message comes up, and, interestingly the plugin finishes loading afterwards. I can't interact with the window but I can move it around lol. Live closes after clicking the "OK" button on the crash message.
For some reason, no crash reports are appearing in Console; I don't suppose the crash report generated by Ableton would be of any help?

@vb-steph
Copy link

vb-steph commented Sep 9, 2024

I'm having these same crashes with the VST3, AU, and Standalone versions. I tested this in Live 10.1.43, Logic Pro 10.7.4, and FL Studio 21.2.1.3430 running on an M1 MacBook Pro with macOS Monterey version 12.2.1. I sent the crash report that was generated from the Standalone version crash, hopefully this helps.

@timothyschoen
Copy link
Collaborator

I think I see the pattern now, it seems all these crashes happen on versions of macOS that are older than what I'm running here.

Could anyone try the latest nightly build (https://glyphpress.com/plugdata/plugdata-macOS-Universal.pkg) and confirm if it's fixed or not?

@offchristianamr
Copy link

offchristianamr commented Sep 10, 2024

Still crashing right away on the nightly build, unfortunately. Tried out v0.9.0 and it does not crash. Thanks for following up on this.

@lockee951
Copy link

Following from holidays. will try it as well when at home (Monte rey)

@timothyschoen
Copy link
Collaborator

Still crashing right away on the nightly build, unfortunately. Tried out v0.9.0 and it does not crash. Thanks for following up on this.

Does the standalone also crash instantly for you? Or only the plugin in Ableton?

@timothyschoen
Copy link
Collaborator

Just installed macOS Monterey in a virtual machine, I can reproduce the crash there!

@timothyschoen
Copy link
Collaborator

After d563115 is done compiling, it should work again!

Sorry it took a while! But this solves the problem on my Monterey VM at least

@offchristianamr
Copy link

I tried out Nightly Build 164b1c6 today and it is no longer crashing on startup on Monterey 12.7.2. Thank you!!

@vb-steph
Copy link

I am still getting the same crash on startup issue on 164b1c6. I updated my OS to Monterey 12.7.6 and the issue still remains.

  • macOS Universal download commit 164b1c6
  • tested VST 3, AU, Standalone plugin
  • M1 MacBook Pro on Monterey 12.7.6
  • happens on 3 different DAWs: Logic 10.7.4, Ableton Live 10.1.43, FL Studio 24.1.1.3936
  • the crash happens when the plugin is clicked on and the plugin window would normally open, not when the plugin is initially loaded in. For example, I can load the plugin in the bottom bar in Ableton but once I click the button to open the plugin window, it crashes.

@timothyschoen
Copy link
Collaborator

I am still getting the same crash on startup issue on 164b1c6. I updated my OS to Monterey 12.7.6 and the issue still remains.

* macOS Universal download commit [164b1c6](https://github.com/plugdata-team/plugdata/commit/164b1c6d4449658aa081bcbf9b6f8b0a069ce5bb)

* tested VST 3, AU, Standalone plugin

* M1 MacBook Pro on Monterey 12.7.6

* happens on 3 different DAWs: Logic 10.7.4, Ableton Live 10.1.43, FL Studio 24.1.1.3936

* the crash happens when the plugin is clicked on and the plugin window would normally open, not when the plugin is initially loaded in. For example, I can load the plugin in the bottom bar in Ableton but once I click the button to open the plugin window, it crashes.

Could you send me the crash report? When if crashes, click "send report", and paste the content of the error message over here. Thanks!

@vb-steph
Copy link

I just downloaded and tested in the standalone and AU versions - the plugin is working again, this issue has been resolved for me. Thanks!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

5 participants