[Bug]: File out of sync after renaming and web text editor 24.0.7 #3964

dhcgn · 2022-12-18T21:52:47Z

⚠️ This issue respects the following points: ⚠️

This is a bug, not a question or a configuration/webserver/proxy issue.
This issue is not already reported on Github (I've searched it).
Nextcloud Server is up to date. See Maintenance and Release Schedule for supported versions.
Nextcloud Server is running on 64bit capable CPU, PHP and OS.
I agree to follow Nextcloud's Code of Conduct.

Bug description

I change a file in the web frontend and the sync file was different to the server file version.

Steps to reproduce

File shared_profile.ps1.age saved through next cloud windows client.

-----BEGIN AGE ENCRYPTED FILE-----
YWdlLWVuY3J5cHRpb24ub3JnL3YxCi0+IFgyNTUxOSA4NG02cXhrSjFBRUxvN2J1
alZoT1c5aEJBcmZ0L2kzWFZOaGx6KzNSaDFFCnhnMDJldFVvMXgwTWpSN1hPbkQx
T2k1U0pCdmxiWkROOUpzSmJ4dTNSemMKLS0tIHZQYUEwUE8zSDFPYW5XVGZ3OTJZ
bTVuRGRzOTB4NEZrUmthZS80b3FXdTgKD5WI4VGuRnPHwfy1fsFXDCFqT0ZlZ4k5
VPbdf3d0x7laQlZo1FzO2clTnOsHO5fbOVVsiRpDEIU1
-----END AGE ENCRYPTED FILE-----

File name changed in server web ui from shared_profile.ps1.age to shared_profile.ps1.age.txt
Modifed file in server web ui with xx with buildin test editor

-----BEGIN AGE ENCRYPTED FILE-----
YWdlLWVuY3J5cHRpb24ub3JnL3YxCi0+IFgyNTUxOSA4NG02cXhrSjFBRUxvN2J1
alZoT1c5aEJBcmZ0L2kzWFZOaGx6KzNSaDFFCnhnMDJldFVvMXgwTWpSN1hPbkQx
T2k1U0pCdmxiWkROOUpzSmJ4dTNSemMKLS0txxIHZQYUEwUE8zSDFPYW5XVGZ3OTJZ
bTVuRGRzOTB4NEZrUmthZS80b3FXdTgKD5WI4VGuRnPHwfy1fsFXDCFqT0ZlZ4k5
VPbdf3d0x7laQlZo1FzO2clTnOsHO5fbOVVsiRpDEIU1
-----END AGE ENCRYPTED FILE-----

4c4
< T2k1U0pCdmxiWkROOUpzSmJ4dTNSemMKLS0tIHZQYUEwUE8zSDFPYW5XVGZ3OTJZ
---
> T2k1U0pCdmxiWkROOUpzSmJ4dTNSemMKLS0txxIHZQYUEwUE8zSDFPYW5XVGZ3OTJZ

File synced with next cloud windows client

-----BEGIN AGE ENCRYPTED FILE-----
YWdlLWVuY3J5cHRpb24ub3JnL3YxCi0+IFgyNTUxOSA4NG02cXhrSjFBRUxvN2J1
alZoT1c5aEJBcmZ0L2kzWFZOaGx6KzNSaDFFCnhnMDJldFVvMXgwTWpSN1hPbkQx
T2k1U0pCdmxiWkROOUpzSmJ4dTNSemMKLS0tIHZQYUEwUE8zSDFPYW5XVGZ3OTJZ
bTVuRGRzOTB4NEZrUmthZS80b3FXdTgKD5WI4VGuRnPHwfy1fsFXDCFqT0ZlZ4k5
VPbdf3d0x7laQlZo1FzO2clTnOsHO5fbOVVsiRpDEIU1
-----END AGE ENCRYPTED FILE-

Local file and file in web ui are out of sync

4c4
< T2k1U0pCdmxiWkROOUpzSmJ4dTNSemMKLS0txxIHZQYUEwUE8zSDFPYW5XVGZ3OTJZ
---
> T2k1U0pCdmxiWkROOUpzSmJ4dTNSemMKLS0tIHZQYUEwUE8zSDFPYW5XVGZ3OTJZ
7c7
< -----END AGE ENCRYPTED FILE-----
---
> -----END AGE ENCRYPTED FILE-

Changed local file to old state:

-----BEGIN AGE ENCRYPTED FILE-----
YWdlLWVuY3J5cHRpb24ub3JnL3YxCi0+IFgyNTUxOSA4NG02cXhrSjFBRUxvN2J1
alZoT1c5aEJBcmZ0L2kzWFZOaGx6KzNSaDFFCnhnMDJldFVvMXgwTWpSN1hPbkQx
T2k1U0pCdmxiWkROOUpzSmJ4dTNSemMKLS0tIHZQYUEwUE8zSDFPYW5XVGZ3OTJZ
bTVuRGRzOTB4NEZrUmthZS80b3FXdTgKD5WI4VGuRnPHwfy1fsFXDCFqT0ZlZ4k5
VPbdf3d0x7laQlZo1FzO2clTnOsHO5fbOVVsiRpDEIU1
-----END AGE ENCRYPTED FILE-----

Changes appear in web front end:

Expected behavior

These files are identical

Installation method

Other Community project

Operating system

None

PHP engine version

PHP 8.0

Web server

Nginx

Database engine version

MySQL

Is this bug present after an update or on a fresh install?

None

Are you using the Nextcloud Server Encryption module?

Encryption is Enabled

What user-backends are you using?

Default user-backend (database)
LDAP/ Active Directory
SSO - SAML
Other

Configuration report

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<ocs>
 <meta>
  <status>ok</status>
  <statuscode>200</statuscode>
  <message>OK</message>
 </meta>
 <data>
  <nextcloud>
   <system>
    <version>24.0.7.1</version>
    <theme>hetzner</theme>
    <enable_avatars>yes</enable_avatars>
    <enable_previews>yes</enable_previews>
    <memcache.local>\OC\Memcache\APCu</memcache.local>
    <memcache.distributed>\OC\Memcache\Redis</memcache.distributed>
    <filelocking.enabled>yes</filelocking.enabled>
    <memcache.locking>\OC\Memcache\Redis</memcache.locking>
    <debug>no</debug>
    <freespace>951914725376</freespace>
    <cpuload>N/A</cpuload>
    <mem_total>-1024</mem_total>
    <mem_free>-1024</mem_free>
    <swap_total>-1024</swap_total>
    <swap_free>-1024</swap_free>
    <apps>
     <num_installed>48</num_installed>
     <num_updates_available>1</num_updates_available>
     <app_updates>
      <contacts>4.2.3</contacts>
     </app_updates>
    </apps>
   </system>
   <storage>
    <num_users>3</num_users>
    <num_files>119754</num_files>
    <num_storages>6</num_storages>
    <num_storages_local>1</num_storages_local>
    <num_storages_home>3</num_storages_home>
    <num_storages_other>2</num_storages_other>
   </storage>
   <shares>
    <num_shares>11</num_shares>
    <num_shares_user>0</num_shares_user>
    <num_shares_groups>0</num_shares_groups>
    <num_shares_link>11</num_shares_link>
    <num_shares_mail>0</num_shares_mail>
    <num_shares_room>0</num_shares_room>
    <num_shares_link_no_password>11</num_shares_link_no_password>
    <num_fed_shares_sent>0</num_fed_shares_sent>
    <num_fed_shares_received>0</num_fed_shares_received>
    <permissions_3_17>11</permissions_3_17>
   </shares>
  </nextcloud>
  <server>
   <webserver>nginx</webserver>
   <php>
    <version>8.0</version>
    <memory_limit>1073741824</memory_limit>
    <max_execution_time>10800</max_execution_time>
    <upload_max_filesize>10737418240</upload_max_filesize>
    <opcache>
     <opcache_enabled>1</opcache_enabled>
     <cache_full/>
     <restart_pending/>
     <restart_in_progress/>
     <memory_usage>
      <used_memory>66951000</used_memory>
      <free_memory>201463496</free_memory>
      <wasted_memory>20960</wasted_memory>
      <current_wasted_percentage>0.0078082084655762</current_wasted_percentage>
     </memory_usage>
     <interned_strings_usage>
      <buffer_size>25165360</buffer_size>
      <used_memory>4979760</used_memory>
      <free_memory>20185600</free_memory>
      <number_of_strings>80391</number_of_strings>
     </interned_strings_usage>
     <opcache_statistics>
      <num_cached_scripts>2231</num_cached_scripts>
      <num_cached_keys>4278</num_cached_keys>
      <max_cached_keys>16229</max_cached_keys>
      <hits>106788472</hits>
      <start_time>1669786698</start_time>
      <last_restart_time>0</last_restart_time>
      <oom_restarts>0</oom_restarts>
      <hash_restarts>0</hash_restarts>
      <manual_restarts>0</manual_restarts>
      <misses>2277</misses>
      <blacklist_misses>0</blacklist_misses>
      <blacklist_miss_ratio>0</blacklist_miss_ratio>
      <opcache_hit_rate>99.997867792837</opcache_hit_rate>
     </opcache_statistics>
     <jit>
      <enabled/>
      <on/>
      <kind>5</kind>
      <opt_level>4</opt_level>
      <opt_flags>6</opt_flags>
      <buffer_size>0</buffer_size>
      <buffer_free>0</buffer_free>
     </jit>
    </opcache>
    <apcu>
     <cache>
      <num_slots>4099</num_slots>
      <ttl>0</ttl>
      <num_hits>4987014</num_hits>
      <num_misses>50989</num_misses>
      <num_inserts>49870</num_inserts>
      <num_entries>833</num_entries>
      <expunges>0</expunges>
      <start_time>1669786698</start_time>
      <mem_size>391240</mem_size>
      <memory_type>mmap</memory_type>
     </cache>
     <sma>
      <num_seg>1</num_seg>
      <seg_size>33554312</seg_size>
      <avail_mem>33099920</avail_mem>
     </sma>
    </apcu>
    <extensions>
     <element>Core</element>
     <element>date</element>
     <element>libxml</element>
     <element>openssl</element>
     <element>pcre</element>
     <element>sqlite3</element>
     <element>zlib</element>
     <element>ctype</element>
     <element>curl</element>
     <element>dom</element>
     <element>fileinfo</element>
     <element>filter</element>
     <element>ftp</element>
     <element>hash</element>
     <element>iconv</element>
     <element>json</element>
     <element>mbstring</element>
     <element>SPL</element>
     <element>PDO</element>
     <element>pdo_sqlite</element>
     <element>session</element>
     <element>posix</element>
     <element>readline</element>
     <element>Reflection</element>
     <element>standard</element>
     <element>SimpleXML</element>
     <element>Phar</element>
     <element>tokenizer</element>
     <element>xml</element>
     <element>xmlreader</element>
     <element>xmlwriter</element>
     <element>mysqlnd</element>
     <element>cgi-fcgi</element>
     <element>apcu</element>
     <element>bcmath</element>
     <element>exif</element>
     <element>gd</element>
     <element>gmp</element>
     <element>imagick</element>
     <element>intl</element>
     <element>ldap</element>
     <element>memcached</element>
     <element>mysqli</element>
     <element>pcntl</element>
     <element>pdo_mysql</element>
     <element>pdo_pgsql</element>
     <element>redis</element>
     <element>smbclient</element>
     <element>sodium</element>
     <element>zip</element>
     <element>libsmbclient</element>
     <element>Zend OPcache</element>
    </extensions>
   </php>
   <database>
    <type>mysql</type>
    <version>10.5</version>
    <size>182910976</size>
   </database>
  </server>
  <activeUsers>
   <last5minutes>2</last5minutes>
   <last1hour>2</last1hour>
   <last24hours>2</last24hours>
  </activeUsers>
 </data>
</ocs>

List of activated Apps

<extensions>
<element>Core</element>
<element>date</element>
<element>libxml</element>
<element>openssl</element>
<element>pcre</element>
<element>sqlite3</element>
<element>zlib</element>
<element>ctype</element>
<element>curl</element>
<element>dom</element>
<element>fileinfo</element>
<element>filter</element>
<element>ftp</element>
<element>hash</element>
<element>iconv</element>
<element>json</element>
<element>mbstring</element>
<element>SPL</element>
<element>PDO</element>
<element>pdo_sqlite</element>
<element>session</element>
<element>posix</element>
<element>readline</element>
<element>Reflection</element>
<element>standard</element>
<element>SimpleXML</element>
<element>Phar</element>
<element>tokenizer</element>
<element>xml</element>
<element>xmlreader</element>
<element>xmlwriter</element>
<element>mysqlnd</element>
<element>cgi-fcgi</element>
<element>apcu</element>
<element>bcmath</element>
<element>exif</element>
<element>gd</element>
<element>gmp</element>
<element>imagick</element>
<element>intl</element>
<element>ldap</element>
<element>memcached</element>
<element>mysqli</element>
<element>pcntl</element>
<element>pdo_mysql</element>
<element>pdo_pgsql</element>
<element>redis</element>
<element>smbclient</element>
<element>sodium</element>
<element>zip</element>
<element>libsmbclient</element>
<element>Zend OPcache</element>
</extensions>

Nextcloud Signing status

No errors have been found.

Nextcloud Logs

No response

Additional info

This instance is a managed hosted from Hetzner
https://www.hetzner.com/storage/storage-share

The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:

mejo- · 2023-05-14T08:18:27Z

Dear @dhcgn, thanks for your report and sorry for not getting back to you earlier. It sounds like you changed the local file while editing the version on your Nextcloud instance at the same time. This creates a conflict because there's changes on both versions. Nextcloud doesn't know which change should take precedence. That's why the Text editor asks for manual resolution.

The Text app nowadays marks files as locked while editing them and I vaguely remember that the support for Windows to respect the file lock was improved as well.

If you're still able to reproduce the issue, please let us know the details how you changed the local file back to original state.

blizzz · 2023-06-23T21:47:41Z

As there is no feedback since a while I will close this ticket. If it still happens, please provide the requested information.

dhcgn added 0. Needs triage bug Something isn't working labels Dec 18, 2022

szaimen transferred this issue from nextcloud/server Mar 17, 2023

mejo- added the needs info label May 14, 2023

mejo- added the needs triage: arthur label Jun 6, 2023

blizzz closed this as completed Jun 23, 2023

blizzz removed the needs triage: arthur label Jun 23, 2023

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

[Bug]: File out of sync after renaming and web text editor 24.0.7 #3964

[Bug]: File out of sync after renaming and web text editor 24.0.7 #3964

dhcgn commented Dec 18, 2022 •

edited

Loading

mejo- commented May 14, 2023

blizzz commented Jun 23, 2023

[Bug]: File out of sync after renaming and web text editor 24.0.7 #3964

[Bug]: File out of sync after renaming and web text editor 24.0.7 #3964

Comments

dhcgn commented Dec 18, 2022 • edited Loading

⚠️ This issue respects the following points: ⚠️

Bug description

Steps to reproduce

Expected behavior

Installation method

Operating system

PHP engine version

Web server

Database engine version

Is this bug present after an update or on a fresh install?

Are you using the Nextcloud Server Encryption module?

What user-backends are you using?

Configuration report

List of activated Apps

Nextcloud Signing status

Nextcloud Logs

Additional info

mejo- commented May 14, 2023

blizzz commented Jun 23, 2023

dhcgn commented Dec 18, 2022 •

edited

Loading