[ FF7 ] Collection of widescreen 16:9 bugs

[CosmosXIII]

This is the collection of bugs related to the new widescreen 16:9 aspect ratio mode.

Common

• 16:9 aspect ratio stretches to fill the screen when displayed on an ultrawide monitor

Field mode

• Some fields show a back bar on the top/bottom of the screen
• The chocobo black screen in the Chocobo Farm does not show
• The wind overlay in Gaea's cliff does not scale to fill the screen
• In fship_22, the vertical scrolling stops too early

Battle mode

• Compact Battle UI has black background on the bottom right and left
• Limit break boxes extend beyond the intended window
• Pollensalta at Northern Cave - The full screen spell texture is not following true widescreen
• Aerith's Great Gospel Limit 4 shows the black background in the edges

Worldmap mode

Other modes

• shop characters/text to appear cut off
• Condor minigame is still 4:3
• credits, game over and start screen are still 4:3

Before reporting new bugs/glitches, make sure you are running the latest canary version of FFNx. Also double check if the bug or glitch is not already in this list

[KuraudoXS]

7th 2.6.14
FFNx 1.13.0.8

Fields

1. fship_24 (fship_2, fship_25 not prolly) - As soon as you step in the Highwind the animation background is not wide, resulting in a black background on both sides close to the animation.
   
2. junbin21 - PSX scene FYR https://youtu.be/ub0qHDFZayE?t=34415 (9:33:35)
   FYI This field has an issue, the camera following Heidegger is going way too up the field and it's showing an "out-of-boundary" area, above the curtains, which is not supposed to be visible.
   

Worldmap

1. The worldmap UI position is not bottom right corner as it was before true widescreen.
   
   

Spells animations

1. Pollensalta at Northern Cave - The full screen spell texture is not following true widescreen
   

FMV

1. Opening Movie transition from CG to Field it's a bit too evident, this is obviously out of scope and low priority but could be an idea to have a "smoke effect from the train" a la FFVII Remake to enhance this? ( YT: https://youtu.be/QQuw6Es6jGc?t=246 4:06 )

Other Mod - Compatibility issue

1. Compact Battle UI has black background right and left. (DEPRECATED, USE IFRIT MOD)
2. ESUI: The command "Defend" and "Change" appear for a frame only and then disappears.
   
3. ESUI + Finishing Touch: Limit break red string is out of the battle window. Possible to replicate selecting mini-faces as a Finishing Touch option. (FIXED)

Specs
CPU: i7-10870H
RAM: 16GB DDR4
GPU: RTX 3060

Resolution 1920x1080
Widescreen on
Internal resolution *4
Antialiasing: off
Antisotropic: on
Vertical sync: on
Advanced Lighting: on

[AnsgarTOdinson]

16:9 aspect ratio stretches to fill the screen when displayed on an ultrawide monitor. Native 4:3 mode does not. This applies to everything. Fields, battles, menus, FMVs, everything.

[tangtang95]

@KuraudoXS found this field map 'junbin21' having some problem with top camera range. Need to fix it in future config.toml

[Sdub-12]

7th v2.6.1.10
FFnx 1.13.0.55 (Located I was unable to locate the number, it was not displaying on the screen for borderless window it was displayed when using Fullscreen. )

Describe the bug
16:9 Mode is causing shop characters/text to appear incorrectly/moved. The issue seems to be specifically to shop prices. Will attach screenshots. Using Canary build.

To Reproduce

1. Go to Gamedriver Settings
2. Enable 16:9 Widescreen
3. Begin Game
4. Enter Shop interface
5. See error

Expected behavior
I expected the prices to appear normally as is with 4:3

Screenshots

Settings I was using

GPU (please complete the following information):

• NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 3GB
• GeForce Game Ready Driver Version 516.94

Additional context
Feel free to reach out to me anytime, I am Sdub in the Qhimm discord

[julianxhokaxhiu]

@Sdub-12 when putting reports please make sure you tell which is the FFNx version you used, not the date. Thank you.

[Sdub-12]

@Sdub-12 when putting reports please make sure you tell which is the FFNx version you used, not the date. Thank you.

Updated, I was unable to locate the number at the time, it was not displaying on the screen for borderless windowed mode, Was displayed when using Fullscreen. Apologies, Ive only been using the program for less than a week

[tangtang95]

@CosmosXIII Regarding the menu shop scissor glitch, it's probably not going inside this if condition https://github.com/julianxhokaxhiu/FFNx/blob/master/src/renderer.cpp#L1237. You did it also for swirl, but is it really necessary?

[CosmosXIII]

@CosmosXIII Regarding the menu shop scissor glitch, it's probably not going inside this if condition https://github.com/julianxhokaxhiu/FFNx/blob/master/src/renderer.cpp#L1237. You did it also for swirl, but is it really necessary?

yeah, I fixed the conditions in this PR and the shop glitch is fixed now: #484
the swirl one did not need that condition so I removed it

[Sdub-12]

Canary
7th v2.6.1.20
FFNx v1.13.0.75

Describe the bug
When doing anything with the Chocobo Farm (Moving, Breeding, Riding) It does not show the Black screen with the chocobo. It instead just shows the top of the barn with the information from the Chocobo as seen in the screenshots below.

To Reproduce
Have widescreen mode on
Attempting to use chocobo farm.

Expected behavior
To be able to see the traditional chocobo screen

Screenshots

GPU (please complete the following information):

NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 3GB
GeForce Game Ready Driver Version 516.94

Additional context
Let me know if you need any further information.

[Neffina]

I noticed that in the penultimate boss fight in 16:9 format, the boss is not really displayed. The pens on his head are too far away. It's not because of the model, if 16:9 is deactivated, everything is correct.

[SirDevil99]

This affect doesn't scale properly in Gaea’s Cliff as it is only a box as shown in the image above.

Canary
7th v2.6.1.20
FFNx v1.13.0.75

GPU RTX3080 - Driver 516.94

[chrcoluk]

If ESUI limit box issue is fixed I appreciate that, I was going to fix inside ESUI itself, so thank you.

[LaZar00]

Using:
Canary
FFNx 1.13.0.83
7H 2.6.1.25

In fship_22, when Cloud reach the tornado, we can see Highwind with Rufus, Heidegger, Scarlet, Hojo... In the 16:9 version, the scroll does not pans to the bottom when Hojo speaks. I leave 4:3 version and 16:9 version to see differences.

Ff7.20220920.00555601-1.mp4

Ff7.20220920.00571802-1.mp4

[LaZar00]

Using:
Canary
FFNx 1.13.0.83
7H 2.6.1.25

I wouldn't say this is a bug, maybe an enhancement.

In trnad_3 (704), I think that the width of the field is enough wide to use the 16:9 proportion. But you must walk for scroll/pan horizontally the field view... I'm not sure if this is normal or it is as is. Obviously I have configured FFNx as 16:9.

UPDATE 20/09/2022: This issue happens also in trnad_4 (705). But changing this maybe it breaks the effect of panning of the stage when appears Sephirot.

FF7.2022.09.20.-.01.21.30.03.mp4

[LaZar00]

Using:
Canary
FFNx 1.13.0.84
7H 2.6.1.25

Another widescreen issue appears the first time we get Highwind (without Cloud). Your character is Tifa and you must go down to the bridge. Then there is a sequence where Barret and Cait are present and there is a pan movement of the field to the right, but then later, the camera stays, because the pan to the left reachs the edge (I assume), and Barret and Cait disappear magically xD.

TifaHightwindScreenPanBug.mp4

[LaZar00]

Using:
Canary
FFNx 1.13.0.84
7H 2.6.1.27

Great Gospel Limit 4 of Aeris shows the black background in the edges of the box:

[CosmosXIII]

@LaZar00 trnad_3 and trnad_4 have scrolling but not enough to fill widescreen. These ones remain 4:3 for now but we are working on solutions for those.

[LaZar00]

@CosmosXIII I was not sure if it would fill all the 16:9 aspect. But it's ok. I only reported it because I've seen some field backgrounds showing all the image even it does not fill 16:9 aspect ratio.
In any case, you are doing a great job with widescreen!

[julianxhokaxhiu]

Closed by mistake. Re-opened.

[LaZar00]

Using: Canary FFNx 1.13.0.84 7H 2.6.1.27

Great Gospel Limit 4 of Aeris shows the black background in the edges of the box:

About this issue, the model/box of the sky it is in magic.lgp. The RSD file using it is SKY_A.RSD, that uses the model SKY_A.P and the texture SKY_1.TEX. Maybe doing bigger that model box the issue is solved.

[LaZar00]

Using:
Canary
FFNx 1.14.0.1
7H 2.7.0.1

I'm checking some of the models of the ESkills, and I've found this issue while using widescreen 16:9. This is the ESkill "Pandora's Box". You can see the bright light of the beginning initiates the left part where 4:3 aspect should be, although it finishes correctly to the right of the screen.

Another issue would be the colored rays that come from behind the question symbol. They seem to be 4:3. I'm not sure if those can be enhanced to accept 16:9.

Ff7.20220926.21040411-1.mp4

[LaZar00]

Using:
Canary
FFNx 1.14.0.1
7H 2.7.0.8

When you go for the Huge materia of Mt. Corel, you have to do the minigame of the little train. In this case, you have to go wagon by wagon until reach the locomotive and stop the train.

In the video you can see how part of the mountain (top left part of the image) is rendered at certain point, leaving some part without rendering. This happens in other camera views of this sequence also.

FF7.2022.09.30.-.21.15.40.02.mp4

[LaZar00]

Using:
Canary
FFNx 1.14.0.1
7H 2.7.0.8

Ok, another magic trick, this time with Young Cloud, like the one of Barret/Cait Sith in Highwind and Tifa. This is one of those that is best to update at field level.

Desktop.20221015.23575602-1.mp4

[chrcoluk]

Something that can affect trying to do WS on vanilla battle layout is if box width is wider than 4:3 size the scroll boxes stop rendering, let me know if you want a clip.

[tangtang95]

Something that can affect trying to do WS on vanilla battle layout is if box width is wider than 4:3 size the scroll boxes stop rendering, let me know if you want a clip.

Yeah, if you have an image, or even a way to test it, it would help a lot

[LaZar00]

Using:
Canary
FFNx 1.14.0.1
7H 2.7.0.8

Well, the last positional bug I found for Widescreen. I think that three are all possible, but who knows. I have not checked 100% of the game.

BeforeParachute.mp4

[LaZar00]

Canary
FFNx 1.15.0.46
7H 3.0.0.1

Found this issue with the sunrays layer of the field. I assume it is widescreen (the other fields seems to work well in widescreen):

[julianxhokaxhiu]

See also #620