S3 Backup script not run automatically by operator

[dashashutosh24]

I have followed the instructions mentioned in : https://jenkinsci.github.io/kubernetes-operator/docs/getting-started/latest/custom-backup-and-restore/ and I have used the exact script given over here. But the backup script is neither run at pod termination nor at the given interval. But since the restore script is being run automatically by the operator, it is failing as there is no object in s3 bucket as the backup script didn't run. I have checked for connectivity to S3 and that is successfully working.

[brokenpip3]

I never tried that backup script.
We can try to official support it by adding it in the repo beside the pvc one and add some tests to be sure it will work correctly. Not a priority atm, if someone wants to try work on this will be super appreciated :)

[MackleX]

I am eager to contribute to the open-source community and would like to offer my assistance with the issue at hand. However, I am having difficulty understanding the specific requirements mentioned by @brokenpip3, particularly the reference to "the PVC one and add some tests." I have a general understanding of the issue, but I would greatly appreciate any additional guidance or clarification. I am excited to begin contributing to the Jenkins community, as they are known for supporting newcomers in tackling beginner-friendly issues.

[brokenpip3]

I am having difficulty understanding the specific requirements mentioned by @brokenpip3, particularly the reference to "the PVC one and add some tests." I have a general understanding of the issue, but I would greatly appreciate any additional guidance or clarification.

Sorry, this is my bad.
As you can see here under backup/pvc https://github.com/jenkinsci/kubernetes-operator/tree/master/backup/pvc we have the pvc backup script that will do the classic backup by storing everything in the pvc that the helm chart create and mount in the jenkins pod.

By supporting the s3 I mean start creating the same structure under a backup/s3 dir to support the s3 backup option that is explained here: https://jenkinsci.github.io/kubernetes-operator/docs/getting-started/latest/custom-backup-and-restore/. With all the tests etc, and also changing the doc about this other backup options that we are going to have.
I can help with the testing/ci part.

(let me know if is not clear)

I am excited to begin contributing to the Jenkins community, as they are known for supporting newcomers in tackling beginner-friendly issues.

yeahhh!

do you want the issue assigned?

[MackleX]

that was clear and well explained from you part, thank you, and yes please i want the issue assigned.

[brokenpip3]

ehi @MackleX any news? do you need help in any way?

[MackleX]

Oooooh ! I totally forget about it, one of my beloved ones died, while i am under the pressure to finish a contribution to Aws migration services by adding a feature to Transformation center at BluAge ( adding support for translating rexx language to Java ) along with my manager before my internship end, so i can land a job at AWS. I will look into it this week and i am really sorry to forget it.

…

On Wednesday, June 28, 2023, Luigi Operoso ***@***.***> wrote: ehi @MackleX <https://github.com/MackleX> any news? do you need help in any way? — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#831 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AR547WIUV5IFCKIL2BWEYIDXNPRZLANCNFSM6AAAAAAXSSLGXY> . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.***>

-- null

[brokenpip3]

sure no issue at all, you can do it even in 1 year, I was just checking if you need any helps from me :)

[qazifahad]

hi @MackleX,
I hope this message finds you well. . The problem described in the issue piqued my interest, especially since it's labeled as beginner-friendly. I am relatively new to the world of open-source contributions , and I'm eager to take on challenges that help me grow my skills. This particular issue seems like a fantastic opportunity for someone at my level to learn and make a meaningful contribution.
I was wondering if you would consider assigning this issue to me.
If you're open to this idea, I'd be grateful for the opportunity. Please let me know your thoughts or if there are any particular steps I should follow to get this issue assigned to me.
Thank you for considering my request. I appreciate your time and consideration.
cc @brokenpip3

[brokenpip3]

@qazifahad looks good to me, @MackleX ?

Anyway any PR it will come it will be great :)

[qazifahad]

@brokenpip3 @dashashutosh24 can you guide me in replicating the issue at my end..any help would be appericiated.