Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
32 lines (23 loc) · 2 KB

PeerReviewSummary_3.6.md

File metadata and controls

32 lines (23 loc) · 2 KB
Raw

Peer Review Summary for Project 3.6 in CMPSC 610 Spring 2020

Overview

In this assignment you are to produce a draft of the third chapter of your thesis. Please use the checklist below to ensure your draft meets the minimum requirements. Then, you are to have your new chapter draft peer reviewed by a colleague. Finally, you must peer review at least one chapter draft of your colleague, fill out the following checklist and answer the questions below.

Deliverables

By the established deadline, you must commit a draft of the third chapter to your project4 repository, submit a GitHub issue to the project4 repository of the author whose chapter you peer reviewed, and commit PeerReviewSummary_3.6 file with the completed checklist of the peer reviewed items.

Peer Review

Chapter Draft Author:

Peer Reviewer:

Date of the review:

Checklist

  • The title of the thesis is appropriate and exciting.
  • The thesis document includes a draft of one completed (new) chapter.
  • The ideas in the chapter are developed logically and thoroughly.
  • The chapter contains an opening and a closing paragraphs.
  • The main idea of the chapter is clearly expressed.
  • The content presented in the written chapter is technically correct.
  • The transition between paragraphs in the chapter is smooth.
  • The overall organization of the written chapter is effective.
  • The new chapter of the thesis consists of at least eight pages.
  • There are no typographical or grammatical errors in the thesis chapter draft.
  • There is no extraneous text in the thesis document.

Summary

Provide a summary of the positive and negative aspects of the thesis chapter draft you have reviewed. Specify any places in the reviewed draft where you did not understand the point, or needed more information, or where something did not seem to belong in the thesis. Describe what information needs to be added to make this thesis chapter draft better? You have to write at least five sentences in this paragraph.