Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

amendment: 2024-A4 Clubs Manager Co-signatory to prevent deadlock with Activate Policy (Primary Signatories) #15

Draft
wants to merge 4 commits into
base: main
Choose a base branch
from

Conversation

sunsetkookaburra
Copy link
Member

@sunsetkookaburra sunsetkookaburra commented Sep 15, 2024

Rationale

  • This is to bring practice in-line with current ActivateUTS policies and procedures.
  • The constitution currently mentions Secretary (now CEO), but they will only act in extraordinary circumstances...
  • According to ActivateUTS policy, there must be one "Primary Signatory" (Pres or as elected; not for the time being or acting) for every transaction;
    • Basically this ensures a UTS student is accountable, as President + Treasurer must be students at time of election according to Activate.
  • If either Primary signatory are absent, we would need the Clubs Manager to co-sign to approve the transaction otherwise it would be blocked (and therefore unable to resolve any debts). Despite the constitution investing transaction ability in any two trustees.
  • A vote by the Executive Committee to request the Clubs Manager's signature would resolve the 'crisis'

@sunsetkookaburra sunsetkookaburra changed the title amendment: Allow co-signatory with Clubs Manager, as CEO will only us… amendment: Allow co-signatory with Clubs Manager, as CEO will only use discretion in outstanding circumstances. Sep 15, 2024
@sunsetkookaburra sunsetkookaburra marked this pull request as draft September 15, 2024 10:15
@sunsetkookaburra sunsetkookaburra changed the title amendment: Allow co-signatory with Clubs Manager, as CEO will only use discretion in outstanding circumstances. amendment(activateuts): Allow co-signatory with Clubs Manager, as CEO will only use discretion in outstanding circumstances. Sep 15, 2024
@sunsetkookaburra sunsetkookaburra changed the title amendment(activateuts): Allow co-signatory with Clubs Manager, as CEO will only use discretion in outstanding circumstances. amendment(2024-A4): Allow co-signatory with Clubs Manager, as CEO will only use discretion in outstanding circumstances. Sep 15, 2024
@sunsetkookaburra sunsetkookaburra force-pushed the amendment-signatories branch 2 times, most recently from 19610ca to 8c5e553 Compare September 15, 2024 23:02
@sunsetkookaburra sunsetkookaburra changed the title amendment(2024-A4): Allow co-signatory with Clubs Manager, as CEO will only use discretion in outstanding circumstances. amendment: 2024-A4A Allow co-signatory with Clubs Manager, as CEO will only use discretion in outstanding circumstances. Sep 15, 2024
…l only use discretion in outstanding circumstances.
CONSTITUTION.md Outdated
@@ -152,7 +153,7 @@ The Trustees shall open and maintain a bank account in the name of and on behalf

### 6.4. Withdrawals and Account Signatories

Monies shall not be drawn except by cheque or orders signed by two trustees or by the Secretary for the time being of the Union who may act as sole signatory on all accounts.
Monies shall not be drawn except by cheque or orders signed by two trustees, or by one trustee and the ActivateUTS Clubs Manager for the time being who will have been given a written explanation, or by the ActivateUTS CEO for the time being who may act as sole signatory on all accounts.
Copy link
Contributor

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

  1. Who provides the written explanation to whom?
  2. A written explanation for what purpose?
  3. What circumstances would arise that would necessitate involving the Clubs Manager?

Copy link
Member Author

@sunsetkookaburra sunsetkookaburra Sep 17, 2024

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Who provides the written explanation to whom?

Not currently explicit - it will be from the Executive Committee.

A written explanation for what purpose?

So that the Clubs Manager can use their discretion as to whether it is appropriate for them to act in place of another Executive.

What circumstances would arise that would necessitate involving the Clubs Manager?

According to ActivateUTS policy, there must be one "Primary Signatory" for every transaction (basically to ensure a UTS student is accountable, as President + Treasurer must be students at election according to Activate).
So if either are absent, we would need the Clubs Manager to co-sign to approve the transaction otherwise it would be blocked and we couldn't resolve any debts.

A previous alternative to this amendment mentioned the two trustees "involving at least the President or Treasurer".
I think I'll update the amendment accordingly given my explanation here.

Thanks @tomchristmas for making sure we properly consider the deeper consequences / reasons for these amendments, and make it explicit too.

@sunsetkookaburra sunsetkookaburra changed the title amendment: 2024-A4A Allow co-signatory with Clubs Manager, as CEO will only use discretion in outstanding circumstances. amendment: 2024-A4A Clubs Manager Co-signatory to prevent deadlock with Activate Policy (Primary Signatories), as CEO only signs in outstanding circumstances. Sep 17, 2024
@sunsetkookaburra sunsetkookaburra changed the title amendment: 2024-A4A Clubs Manager Co-signatory to prevent deadlock with Activate Policy (Primary Signatories), as CEO only signs in outstanding circumstances. amendment: 2024-A4 Clubs Manager Co-signatory to prevent deadlock with Activate Policy (Primary Signatories), as CEO only signs in outstanding circumstances. Sep 17, 2024
@sunsetkookaburra sunsetkookaburra changed the title amendment: 2024-A4 Clubs Manager Co-signatory to prevent deadlock with Activate Policy (Primary Signatories), as CEO only signs in outstanding circumstances. amendment: 2024-A4 Clubs Manager Co-signatory to prevent deadlock with Activate Policy (Primary Signatories) Sep 17, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants